President Bush Speech Transcripts / Video
ATTACK
on AMERICA

Bush defends investigation tactics

11/30/2001

By RON FOURNIER
AP White House Correspondent

Bush speaks in the Rose Garden
AP/Ron Edmonds

WASHINGTON — Brushing aside criticism, President Bush defended his authorization of military tribunals and the questioning of Middle Easterners in the United States. ``We're an open society, but we're at war,'' the president said Thursday.

``We will act with fairness and we will deliver justice, which is far more than terrorists ever grant to their innocent victims,'' the president told federal prosecutors visiting the White House.

The speech was Bush's most forceful defense of the administration's investigation tactics after the Sept. 11 attacks. The tactics include authorization of military courts to try non-citizen suspects, interviews with hundreds of people of Middle Eastern descent, secret detentions and the monitoring of jailhouse conversations between lawyers and clients.

Military tribunals can hold closed-door trials and afford fewer rights for the accused than civilian U.S. courts. For example, two-thirds of a jury can convict in a military court, as opposed to the unanimous civilian court verdicts.

Bush, citing precedent from World War II and the Civil War, signed an order to authorize the courts and give himself power to decide who would be tried before them. Aides say it could be weeks or months before the first tribunal is formed, if ever.

Some lawmakers, including Republicans, and civil liberties groups have questioned whether the military courts would violate due process rights.

Bush's response: ``Non-U.S. citizens who plan and-or commit mass murder are more than criminal suspects. They are unlawful combatants who seek to destroy our country and our way of life. And if I determine that it is in the national security interests of our great land to try by military commission those who make war on America, then we will do so.''

Applause filled the theater where prosecutors gathered, across a private street from the West Wing.

White House lawyers say military trials, which can be conducted overseas or aboard ships, might be needed to protect jurors, ensure safe trials and keep confidential intelligence from becoming public.

``One of the prime reasons for doing this is that it will allow us to use intelligence information that we couldn't use in a regular court proceeding in order to bring these people to justice and, at the same time, be able to protect the sources of information,'' Vice President Dick Cheney said in an interview Thursday with ABC's ``Primetime Thursday'' and ``Good Morning America.''

``One of the reasons bin Laden is so good today with his security is because he's gone to school on it,'' Cheney said. ``He's learned from previous leaks, and previous disclosures in the press, and previous disclosures in trials how we operate, and he then adjusts his style of operation and we then lose access to information about what he's doing.''

Bush's defense: ``We're an open society, but we're at war. The enemies declared war on us. We must not let foreign enemies use those forms of liberty to destroy liberty itself. Foreign terrorists and agents must never again be allowed to use our freedoms against us.''

A majority of Americans — six in 10 — supported holding military trials for suspected non-citizen terrorists, according to a recent poll. About nine in 10 said they support the detentions of more than 600 people in the terrorism investigation.

Bush defended the Justice Department's attempt to interview American residents of Middle Eastern descent, including those with no known connection to the attacks.

``We're interviewing people on a voluntary basis. We're saying, `Welcome to America. You come to our country, why don't you help make us safe? Why don't you share information with us? Why don't you help protect innocent people, women and children? Why don't you help us value life? As you enjoy the freedoms of our country help us protect those freedoms,''' Bush said.

Critics of the practice say the administration is snagging innocent people in a dragnet.

In Afghanistan, the president said, troops are routing the Taliban and have al-Qaida terrorists on the run. ``We will patiently, diligently pursue them until they are brought to justice,'' he said.

Bush reminded the attorneys that catching and prosecuting terrorists is not their only job. They also must fight street crime, including gun violations.

``We must help people claim their neighborhoods and their streets,'' he said.



Breaking News | U.S. Strikes Back | Bioterror |Attack Aftermath | The U.S. Response
Economic Impact | The Investigation | The Middle East | Analysis/Perspective | Military Action
Images/Multimedia | En Español | Journalist Bios